In researching for background information on my ancestors, I learned that a pilgrim man tossed his cloth dinner napkin over his shoulder so it would be close to his mouth. The women did the lady-like thing and lay the napkin across their lap. They all ate with spoons and knives because they had not yet been introduced to the Italian utensils with prongs until the 1700s.
Considerate as they were, during the first Thanksgiving celebration, they left all the spoons inside the house. The Native Americans did not use utensils, so the pilgrims thought to forego the habit for that day, in order to accommodate their guests.
They ate Fricasseed Mushrooms, Apple Frazes and Black Pepper Cake with molasses similar to a gingerbread loaf. It kept well without spoiling. A Bride Ale Cake would be found at every Puritan wedding table.
Thanks to the Native Americans who aided the pilgrims (mostly city people) and taught them how to care for themselves. They introduced the Pilgrims to shellfish gems from the sea, how to fish, foraging the forests for mushrooms, fruits, and berries. Before long, pigs, lambs and cows were being supplied from England to add to the wildlife hunted. Chickens laid the eggs for puddings and tarts. After that first devastating year, the Pilgrims were well fed.
From the original Mayflower group, only four women survived that first winter to cook for this celebration. Native American women also brought foods to the feast.
Month: October 2026
1600S PILGRIM WEDDINGS
The Pilgrims considered a wedding a civil contract not a religious one. Miles Standish performed the marriage service for ancestors Samuel Fuller and Jane Lothrop. He came on the Mayflower as a 12 year old, Jane came several years later. For the celebration and in the absence of Samuel’s parents, his neighbor Mrs. Cudworth baked a traditional and beautiful Bride Ale Cake. It was spicey and filled with dried fruits and nuts drenched with brandy then drizzled with a white boiled icing. The Cudworths were especially pleased the Fullers would be growing a family nearby. Jane’s father, Rev. Lothrop supplied plenty of beer, wood pressed cider and wine. He was first to raise his glass with blessings. Music was supplied by members of the Scituate church. Everyone would dance into the night. Samuel and Jane began their life together with good friends, good food, good music, good drink, and they had each other.
